Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
Quantity:
Subtotal
Taxes
Shipping
Total
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

Our Ingredients

At The Pie Lady, all of our desserts are created from scratch using the freshest ingredients sourced locally when possible. The secret to our pies lie in the ingredients, we use ORGANIC butter, cage-free eggs, ORGANIC sugars, premium extracts and spices in all our recipes.

At The Pie Lady, we firmly believe that all of our desserts should taste just as wonderful as they look !

Why The Pie Lady

What sets The Pie Lady apart from the rest is simple. We use the best all natural, non-GMO, organic ingredients and premium extracts. We do not use GMO’s, corn syrup or fillers because we believe that simple, wholesome ingredients create the best tasting desserts around.

All of our creations are "handcrafted from scratch" and only made in small batches and made to order. With The Pie Lady you can be assured that you will not be getting a mass produced pr​oduct that has been sitting in a freezer for months.

Let’s not forget our pie crusts, which are freshly made from ORGANIC all-vegetable shortening and hand rolled to order. 

ORGANIC CLASSIC PIES

Sinful Bourbon Pecan Pie

A sinful mixture of our traditional pecan pie filling with a bourbon twist baked in our flaky hand rolled pie crust

$30.00

Pecan Pie

Ma-Maw's signature pecan pie filling NO CORN SYRUP is used . Baked in our flaky hand rolled pie crust

$30.00

Apple Pie

Crisp apples covered in sugar and spices topped with a lattice or double flaky hand rolled crust

$23.00

Peach Pie

Juicy and sweet peach filling between a lattice topped flaky hand rolled crust  

$23.00

Caramel Apple Pie

Homemade caramel sauce and organic ingredients with crisp apples topped with a lattice flaky hand rolled crust

$25.00

Cherry Pie

Juicy slow stirred cherry filling with organic ingredients between a flaky pie crust

$25.00

Nana's Sweet Potato Pie

Decadent mixture of organic yams, butter, eggs, sugar in our signature flaky pie crust

$23.00

Pumpkin Patch Pie

Organic ingredients with pumpkin puree baked on our flaky hand rolled pie crust

$23.00

ORGANIC SPECIALTY PIES

Cherry Cheese Pie

Cream cheese mixture on top of cherry pie filling topped with sour cream and sprinkle of nutmeg baked in a scrumptious flaky pie crust

$25.00

Pineapple Cheese Pie

Pineapple mixture and creamy cream cheese filling baked on top of our hand rolled flaky pie crust

$25.00

Lemon Chess Pie​  

Classic southern pie with organic butter, sugar, eggs and fresh lemon juice are whisked and baked in our homemade flaky pie crust

$23.00

Buttermilk Pie

Sweet buttermilk custard fills this old time southern dessert in our signature flaky pie crust

$23.00

Chocolate Pecan Pie

Our signature pecan pie filling with chocolate on bottom baked in our flaky pie crust

$30.00

Key Lime Pie

Creamy and tangy key lime filling using real key limes in our house made cookie crumb crust

$25.00

Blackberry Peach Pie

Organic ingredients with juicy fresh peach and blackberry filling between a lattice topped flaky hand rolled crust

$25.00

Mixed Berry Pie

Ripe blueberries, raspberries, strawberries and blackberries in a homemade filling between a lattice topped flaky hand rolled crust

$23.00